CIC Theater’s Journey to a New Home

Many in Chicago’s improv comedy scene agree: on stage, mistakes become opportunities. This philosophy guides Farrell Walsh, artistic and managing director of CIC Theater, both in performance and theater management. Setbacks prompt assessment of goals and future directions. Walsh summarizes this approach to challenges as handling issues, ‘one disaster at a time.’

Describing situations at CIC Theater might seem exaggerated when the aim is often humor. Yet, subtlety is rare in improv comedy. Walsh has been leading CIC’s search for a new permanent venue after leaving their long-term site at 1422 W. Irving Park Road in 2022. Since the early 2000s, Walsh has been involved with CIC, transitioning from performer to artistic director. Initially, CIC’s activities occurred at The Cornservatory on Lincoln Avenue, offering improvised shows, sketches, and full-length plays.

In 2005, he became the artistic director as CIC moved to Irving Park. With COVID-19 striking in 2020, their landlord allowed a temporary rent reduction, keeping CIC viable. By early 2022, new building owners initially continued this arrangement, but new lease terms failed to materialize. Facing the end of the lease in May, CIC returned to a more mobile operation reminiscent of earlier days.

In fall 2022, CIC arranged to use the backroom of Finley Dunne’s Tavern on Lincoln Avenue as a performance space. Weekly shows featured student teams, guests, and a house team. Walsh stated, ‘That was the best use of the two nights,’ which helped maintain continuity.

Classes continued at a nearby rehearsal space. Walsh emphasizes maintaining community ties. CIC, while not as famous as iO or The Second City, focuses on collaborations that link scenes organically—what Walsh calls, ‘playing vertically.’ This technique enhances continuity and momentum without needing numerous resets.

In November 2025, CIC left Finley Dunne’s, seeking new venues in Lakeview and North Center. After evaluating over 100 spaces, obstacles persisted, from costly renovations to unaffordable rents. CIC turned to a different approach, inspired by the success at Finley Dunne’s. A venue combining bar and theater was ideal.

Eventually, Walsh and partner Kyle McCabe identified 4301 N. Western Avenue, a former Celtic Crown location, as suitable. With its tavern setup and theater space, it was a perfect fit. By July 2025, The Western Bar & Kitchen opened, blending Walsh’s Arizona experiences into its theme. After significant work on theater spaces, CIC aims to welcome the public.

Walsh stresses supporting the community that has aided them, a core nonprofit mission. A crowdfunding campaign raised more than $25,000, supported by local improvisers and other donors. Classes continue, and the tavern serves patrons. CIC plans a grand opening for the theater in the fall.

The community’s strong backing suggests a warm reception when the audience finally returns.