Illinois Legislative Inspector General Faces Criticism Over Handling Harassment Case

In a report released by Illinois Legislative Inspector General Michael McCuskey last month, allegations of sexual harassment against ex-state Rep. Harry Benton were substantiated. One victim, a female lobbyist, expressed dissatisfaction with McCuskey’s portrayal of her account. McCuskey, formerly a state and federal judge, denied inaccuracies, stating, “My judgments have never been attacked by an individual doubting my credibility!” Despite his defense, the lobbyist sent a letter to Illinois’ top four legislative leaders, criticizing McCuskey’s methods and comments during her interview.

The lobbyist’s letter claims McCuskey violated confidentiality, shared inappropriate comments, and mishandled investigative norms. Specific complaints include sharing the names of other victims, disclosing confidential information, and inappropriate comments about her appearance. In her letter to legislative leaders, she described instances where McCuskey allegedly breached privacy by sharing details of other victims’ cases.

These claims emerged after McCuskey concluded Benton had engaged in a “pattern and practice” of sexual harassment against the lobbyist and two other women. Benton, a Democrat from Plainfield, resigned on July 3. Furthermore, attention is now on House Speaker Welch’s initial handling of the case. Questions arise over Welch’s delay in disciplining Benton after one woman reported harassment in 2023.

A recent radio interview by McCuskey sparked concerns about his approach. He admitted not taking notes during his interaction with the lobbyist, raising eyebrows in political circles. The lobbyist alleged it seemed McCuskey didn’t record the interview, a point he hasn’t disputed.

The Tribune initially detailed allegations against Benton last month. Reports from Benton’s former staffer and the lobbyist highlighted incidents of harassment, including lewd remarks and inappropriate touching. Welch only removed Benton from duties in February, after the lobbyist reported Benton’s misconduct at a Chicago bar.

“It is crucial for the Legislative Ethics Commission to address these issues promptly. Our process must be impartial and protect victim confidentiality,” stated Senate Republican Leader Curran.

Senate President Harmon’s spokesperson emphasized the need for respectful treatment of victims and witnesses. Spokespeople for Welch and McCombie declined to comment.

McCuskey’s decision not to record interviews stems from concerns it may deter victims from reporting future cases. Republican state Rep. Jeff Keicher, who chairs the Legislative Ethics Commission, acknowledged the seriousness of the concerns raised but avoided specifics due to confidentiality guidelines.

The commission, comprising four Democratic and four Republican legislators, supervises McCuskey’s work. McCuskey maintained that allegations against him are reviewed in confidence by the commission.