Menu

Appeals Court Reviews DOJ’s Request on California Ballots

3 weeks ago 0

A federal appeals court is examining the Trump administration’s emergency bid to force California to hold aside thousands of mail-in ballots tied to individuals suspected of being noncitizens. This effort comes ahead of the midterm elections.

The three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit delved into the government’s legal reasons and questioned the court’s jurisdiction. Attorneys from both the Trump administration and California presented their arguments over a nearly two-hour hearing. The federal government urged the panel to make an immediate decision, noting that hundreds of thousands of California ballots could be counted daily as the dispute persists.

This scrutiny follows an emergency request by the Trump administration. They called for the suspension of approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots sent to suspected noncitizens. The DOJ advised California officials to separate ballots linked to these individuals for eligibility verification rather than processing them like regular votes.

During the hearing, Circuit Judge Mark Bennett, appointed by Trump, queried the compatibility of the injunction with the Constitution’s Elections Clause. This clause gives state legislatures control over election timing, location, and procedures, subject to congressional oversight.

“It seems to me that you want us to issue an injunction that is entirely inconsistent with the law that the California legislature has adopted pursuant to the Elections Clause,” Bennett remarked.

Questions arose about the Ninth Circuit’s jurisdiction at this stage. Judge Gabriel Sanchez, a Biden appointee, asked why intervention was needed when the district court’s decision was pending, with a hearing set before U.S. District Judge David Carter.

Judge Patrick Bumatay, another Trump appointee, concentrated on issues related to potential noncitizen voting and California’s handling of challenges concerning suspected ineligible voters.

The DOJ sought emergency relief from the appeals court after a deadline passed without a ruling from Judge Carter. California argued that the Ninth Circuit should wait for the lower court’s decision.

On Oct. 15, the Justice Department initially filed the suit, shortly after California began sending out ballots.

The Trump administration accused California of “mishandling voter rolls.” California, countering the federal claims, stated it had effective safeguards against noncitizen voting. Los Angeles County identified discrepancies in the federal data, citing individuals born in the U.S. or not registered to vote.

In recent filings, California argued that the federal approach conflicts with constitutional principles, emphasizing the lack of federal authority in election administration that isn’t governed by congressional laws.

So far, more than 3 million votes have been cast statewide, including over 500,000 in Los Angeles County.

The DOJ highlighted the urgency, stressing that every delay risks more ballots being processed before resolving the citizenship dispute.

Bennett assured the panel would strive to rule swiftly.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *