Federal Judge’s Decision
A federal judge has denied the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) request to have California election officials set aside approximately 20,000 ballots allegedly cast by noncitizens. The judge expressed concern that this attempt poses a threat to democracy.
The DOJ sought a temporary restraining order against election officials in California and Los Angeles County. This order would have required segregating ballots from potential noncitizen voters while litigation is ongoing. However, Judge David O. Carter stated that allowing such actions based on unproven allegations could endanger democracy.
“If the Executive can discount votes and threaten an ongoing election due to unproven allegations, then our democracy is in danger,” Judge Carter wrote. “Eroded trust in our democracy is irreparable. Once a vote is segregated, lasting harm has occurred.”
Reasons Behind the Decision
Judge Carter found that the government failed to demonstrate a likelihood of success on the merits of its claims. He noted that their request could disrupt the election, discourage voters, and undermine the votes of U.S. citizens. Additionally, he highlighted that the DOJ has filed over 30 federal lawsuits for voter rolls access without succeeding in any.
The judge questioned the federal government’s standing and whether federal law allows intervention as the DOJ sought. Carter also clarified that federal laws barring noncitizen voting do not override California’s procedures. The evidence provided by the DOJ was deemed unreliable due to inaccuracies in citizenship databases.
The court cited concerns about false positives in identifying noncitizen voters. Carter emphasized that altering voting procedures during an active election could create confusion and disenfranchise lawful voters.
Purcell Principle
A significant factor in Carter’s ruling was the “Purcell principle,” from the Supreme Court’s 2006 decision in Purcell v. Gonzalez. This principle discourages last-minute changes to election rules that could confuse voters and administrators.
The court concluded that the DOJ’s proposed actions required altering established procedures during an election, a step it would not take.
Ongoing Debate on Noncitizen Voting
The case is part of a broader discussion on noncitizen voting and election integrity. Federal law prohibits noncitizens from voting in federal elections. Still, experts debate accurately identifying noncitizens without mistakenly disqualifying legitimate voters, especially naturalized citizens.
Carter noted that existing mechanisms allow the government to investigate and address unlawful voting without segregating ballots. The ruling permits California officials to continue counting ballots under current state procedures.
The DOJ’s Legal Actions
The DOJ provided California with a list of over 20,000 names believed to be noncitizens. California declined to implement the DOJ’s measures within the set timeframe, leading to a lawsuit against California officials.
U.S. Citizen and Immigration Services (USCIS) used its data to identify potential noncitizen voters. USCIS claims to have “high-confidence” matches based on multiple identifiers. Federal agencies cross-referenced state voter records with federal alien records and used additional data sources to eliminate false positives.
USCIS shared a list with Homeland Security Investigations indicating the 20,000 individuals were likely noncitizens registered to vote in California. The DOJ highlighted that these individuals have been manually verified, and the number might increase.

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller