A judge in Sullivan County held oral arguments to decide if New York Attorney General Letitia James should be removed as the special prosecutor in a criminal investigation into an alleged gang rape at Cornell University. The judge, James Farrell, has yet to issue a ruling following the proceedings.
Defense attorney Andrew Miltenberg, representing Gillio Lopes, one of the accused individuals, filed the challenge. Lopes is among seven former members of the Chi Phi fraternity accused of drugging and raping a female Cornell student at their fraternity house in October 2024.
New York Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James previously attended a press conference regarding the investigation.
Miltenberg argued that James’s prior social media comments indicate a pre-existing bias. James had expressed sympathy for the victim, stating, “What this young woman has been forced to endure is horrific and unacceptable.” Miltenberg labeled these statements as an “original sin” requiring James’s removal to preserve the investigation’s impartiality.
Assistant Attorney General Kaitlin Vigars defended James’s role, asserting that public statements do not fulfill the legal criteria for disqualification. Vigars argued that disqualification requires evidence of actual prejudice, not speculative bias claims.
Judge Farrell questioned Vigars on several points regarding James’s appointment, including whether Governor Hochul was aware of James’s comments and if their joint public appearance compromised professional conduct standards.
The judge also raised concerns about procedural consistency, cautioning against potential chaotic outcomes from conflicting legal decisions.
Governor Hochul appointed James as special prosecutor after the local Tompkins County district attorney declined to pursue charges. Hochul’s intervention was aimed at assuring the investigation’s thoroughness and neutrality.
Following the hearing, Hochul stated that sexual offense complaints at Cornell University would be handled by New York State Police unless the individual requests otherwise. She emphasized the importance of safety and trust in institutional protections for survivors of sexual assault.
A formal ruling from Judge Farrell on James’s continuation as special prosecutor is anticipated soon.

Former Hospital Security Guard Convicted for Sexual Conduct with a Dead Body
Northern Illinois University Students Charged After Damaging Mascot Statue
Lindsay Clancy’s Retrial Set for March 29
Former CIA Director’s Son Arrested on Child Pornography Charges
New Charges in White House Correspondents’ Dinner Shooting
New York Fugitive Arrested in Miami Beach for Multiple Assaults