College basketball is underway, bringing back familiar debates between human polls and analytics models. An annual examination reviews discrepancies between the AP Top 25, KenPom’s rankings, and others throughout the season.
Last season showcased notable discrepancies. For instance, KenPom ranked Vanderbilt 19th, much higher than the AP’s effective 36th. Vanderbilt ultimately impressed with a 27-9 finish and a No. 5 seed. However, KenPom overestimated Baylor, ranking them 17th. The Bears ended with a 17-17 record, missing out on the tournament.
UCONN Basketball Coach Considers Game at White House
The AP’s No. 5 team, St. John, struggled early yet finished strong, validating initial optimism. Conversely, the AP ranked Creighton 23rd against KenPom’s 41st, which proved accurate as Creighton fell short of expectations, missing the NCAA Tournament.
This season adds TeamRankings and the Coaches Poll to the mix. Examining Kansas, predictions diverge; the AP ranks them 17th, while KenPom places them fifth. Iowa State sees a similar split, ranked 18th by the AP but sixth in KenPom, supported by their strong defense.
Alabama and Houston also draw differing views. Alabama’s AP rank is 20th, but KenPom places them ninth. Houston stands 10th in the AP, but KenPom gives them a top defensive rating and a third place overall.
John Calipari Comments on Arkansas’ Schedule
Human polls show differing support for USC and Tennessee. USC ranks in the Top 25 for voters but not in the analytics. Tennessee had voter confidence last year, reflected in this season’s polls.
Arkansas, ranked 12th in the AP, finds itself 19th in KenPom. BYU is another team with a split view, ranking 25th in human polls but outside the Top 30 in analytics.
Nebraska, coming off historical success, sees significantly improved rankings from both sides. They’re now 15th in KenPom, contrasting last year’s lack of preseason recognition.
Ohio State and Vanderbilt highlight further differences. Vanderbilt is ranked higher in KenPom than in human polls, reflecting its potential despite early tournament exits.
UConn rounds out the disparities. Despite a strong AP presence, KenPom ranks them 11th. However, TeamRankings contradicts this, placing UConn third.
As the season moves forward, these initial rankings create a framework for analysis. The success of human versus computer predictions will unfold over the coming months.

Challenges Facing US Soccer: Insights from Mauricio Pochettino
Giants’ Historic 2008 Upset Gets Spotlight in New Netflix Documentary
AEW’s Blood and Guts: A Glimpse into the Brutal Spectacle
Nationals Retain Jacob Young with Four-Year Contract
TNA Destination X: A Night of High Stakes and Intense Matches
Kenneth Walker’s Injury and Impact on Kansas City Chiefs