Menu

Energy Prices and Their Impact on U.S. Midterm Elections

1 week ago 0

As the 2026 midterm election results overwhelmed Democrats and Republicans, the long-standing political belief in America resurfaced: “It’s the economy, stupid.” Originally coined by Democratic strategist James Carville in 1992 to guide Bill Clinton, energy prices arguably play an equally crucial role. Energy costs deeply affect the economy, intertwining with politics, especially as gasoline prices climb.

Historically, midterms prove challenging for sitting presidents and often shift power dynamics in Washington, D.C. Crude oil and petroleum product prices, such as gasoline, are driven by global economic forces beyond any president’s or Congress’s control. These prices get dictated on the global stage, impacted by supply and demand. Most oil travels by ocean tankers, with over 20% passing through the Strait of Hormuz, a critical passage that during much of 2026 has been affected by conflict with Iran.

Rising energy costs often cause hikes in other prices like food, triggering inflation spikes both regionally and nationally. When gasoline prices soar, incumbents face lower reelection chances. For the 2026 midterms, gasoline reached record highs, placing Republicans in a tough spot regarding their track record. Historical evidence shows how four U.S. presidents—Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, and Joe Biden—dealt with the political consequences of high fuel costs and inflation in midterms.

Nixon and Ford’s Dilemmas

Richard Nixon encountered a major energy crisis that became political. During the 1973 Yom Kippur War, the U.S. backing Israel led Arab members of OPEC to cut production and embargo oil exports to the U.S., reducing output by 5% monthly. Crude oil prices shot up 184%, from $4.31 to $10.31 per barrel by March 1974. Despite Nixon’s price controls, U.S. gasoline saw a 32% increase. Nixon’s resignation in 1974 amid Watergate scandals brought Gerald Ford to power during a 12.3% inflation era. Preceding the midterms that year, Ford’s “Whip Inflation Now” campaign couldn’t curb losses, as Republicans saw a drop of 48 House seats and five Senate seats. By 1976, gas prices, adjusted for 2026 figures, stood at $3.49 per gallon; Ford lost the 1976 election to Carter.

Economic Struggles Under Carter

In Carter’s first two years starting in 1977, U.S. gasoline prices remained elevated and inflation peaked at 9% in 1978. This resulted in Democrats losing 15 House and three Senate seats in midterms. By the 1980 presidential race, gas prices doubled compared to 1976 levels in real terms. Troubled by economic challenges and the Iranian hostage crisis, Carter lost to Reagan.

Reagan’s Economic Strategies

Ronald Reagan’s policies, known as “Reaganomics,” aligned with tax reductions, deregulation, and controlled government spending. By the mid-1980s, escalated production from the U.S. and non-OPEC regions led to an oil surplus, plummeting crude oil prices. During 1982’s midterms, Republicans saw losses of 26 House seats, gaining one Senate seat. While Reagan won decisively in 1984, 1986’s midterms continued challenging incumbents, with Republicans losing five House and eight Senate seats despite low oil and gas prices.

Trump’s First Presidency

During Trump’s initial presidency, crude prices rose roughly 24% leading up to the 2018 midterms, with gasoline prices up 22%. Consequently, Republicans lost 41 House seats while gaining two Senate seats.

The Biden Administration

The COVID-19 pandemic severely reduced economic activity in 2020, causing a stark drop in U.S. crude oil production and a 40% fall in gasoline demand. The pandemic-induced supply chain disruptions increased energy prices. From the November 2020 elections to the 2022 Ukraine conflict, U.S. unleaded gasoline prices surged 66%, compounded by rekindled demand as pandemic restrictions lifted. Upon assuming office in 2021, Biden released oil reserves to moderate prices, but some policy moves, like halting the Keystone XL project, hampered energy supplies. Inflation reached a 40-year high of 9.1% in June 2022, with gasoline peaking at $4.929 per gallon. Despite anticipated losses, Democrats only lost nine House seats and one Senate seat in 2022.

Trump’s Second Term Considerations

During Trump’s second presidency, crude prices decreased by 4.5%, while production increased by 3.3% to 13.7 million barrels per day. The average gasoline price fell 4.5%, reaching $2.98 per gallon. But on February 28, 2026, U.S. military action in Iran disrupted global oil supplies, with shipment volumes initially plunging before recovering later in the year. Increased pipeline usage from Saudi Arabia and the UAE helped maintain crude export levels. By November 3, 2026, war and political factors had propelled the national average gasoline price to $4.15 per gallon.

Insights and Consequences

As anticipated by pre-election polls, voters attributed inflated gasoline and grocery prices and an unfavorable war to Trump’s administration, echoing a vital economic principle: Economic wellness boosts incumbents’ electoral support while pessimism fuels opposition.

Michael A. Mische, Associate Professor of the Practice of Management and Organization, Marshall School of Business, University of Southern California

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *