In 2018, Gavin Newsom ran for California governor, promising bold action over mediocrity. Now, as a two-term governor known for taking significant political risks, he has followed through by offering clemency to every inmate sentenced to death in California. This decision comes amid speculation about how this mass commutation might influence his potential presidential bid in 2028. Newsom sent a clear message to Americans regarding his leadership style.
“If my job is just to read the polls, you can have an AI chatbot as governor,” Newsom said. “I was hired for my judgment, and like it or hate it, that’s why I think I was given this privilege. My job’s leadership, not stewardship. It’s to lead. I’m here to change polls, change minds.”
This sweeping decision occurs over 20 years after Newsom’s rise to national prominence when he, as San Francisco mayor, defied federal law by allowing same-sex marriages. Newsom’s leadership is marked by bold decisions, such as the stay-at-home order during the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic and spearheading Proposition 50 to redraw California’s congressional districts. He describes such decisions as part of his core beliefs, driven by standing up for ideals and addressing injustice.
On the death penalty, Newsom stated that it is not administered equally. He referenced Bryan Stevenson, founder of Equal Justice Initiative, who remarked on the disparity in outcomes for rich and guilty versus poor and innocent defendants. “I couldn’t not have done this,” Newsom said. “There was an easy out, but I would have felt ashamed of myself.”
By commuting the death sentences of 548 inmates, Newsom challenges the bounds of his authority. California voters have rejected measures to abolish the death penalty in 2012 and 2016, and Newsom’s decision undermines court and state laws allowing capital punishment. Under the state Constitution, Newsom can commute about 40% of the death sentences alone. Cases with previous felony convictions require California Supreme Court approval, ensuring no abuse of power.
Despite Newsom’s actions, capital punishment remains legal in California, and prosecutors can seek death penalties. Critics, including Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman and Sacramento County Sheriff Jim Cooper, voiced opposition. Hochman stated that his office will evaluate eligible cases with care and restraint, while Cooper urged Newsom to reconsider, highlighting the impact on victims’ families.
Some accuse Newsom of reducing sentences for political gain. Riverside County District Attorney Michael Hestrin criticized the decision as disregarding victims and justice. National polls indicate two-thirds of voters favor the death penalty for murder convictions. Political analysts note that Newsom’s actions enhance his progressive credentials, but Republicans might cast him as soft on crime.
Political science professor Gar Culbert suggested that catering to the Democratic base could be advantageous for Newsom. Culbert questioned whether the decision was strategic or simply what Newsom believed was right. Newsom first issued a moratorium on executions in 2019, labeling capital punishment discriminatory and unjust. Without the moratorium, 45 inmates would currently face execution.
Daniel Zingale, Newsom’s former advisor, remarked that the governor cared little for polls on this matter. “His view, and I agree with this, is this is not an issue that you can leverage politically.” Newsom’s commutations have little practical effect as California hasn’t executed anyone since 2006. At his command, the death chamber was dismantled at San Quentin.
With no imminent need for commutations, Newsom said many advised him to avoid action to remain politically safe. Acknowledging risks to a presidential run, Newsom stated, “I’m not an idiot. The ads write themselves. But I wouldn’t be myself. If I’m going to be up there and not be myself, I couldn’t do that.” As his term winds down, Newsom expressed that he does not want to leave with regrets, saying he’s been willing to take risks. “If others aren’t willing to do it, you know what? I’ll raise my hand, and I’m happy, honestly, to take the hits.”

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller