Menu

Jewish Doctor Receives Exemption from Union Fees Due to Religious Beliefs

5 days ago 0

A Jewish doctor in Philadelphia has secured an exemption from union membership and fees. Dr. Jacob Agronin challenged a financial requirement that he said contradicted his religious beliefs. This decision came after America First Legal (AFL) intervened with the Committee of Interns and Residents (CIR), Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 1957.

AFL highlighted the union’s positions on Israel, including backing the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement and accusing Israel of practices like apartheid. The collective bargaining agreement with Temple University Hospital mandated union membership or payment of agency fees for employees under it.

Megan Redshaw, counsel for AFL, explained that Dr. Agronin did not contest the union’s right to political expression. The issue arose as the union’s views impacted his workplace, creating a Title VII matter. Financial support, he believed, violated his religious tenets, even without funding political activities.

The union had confirmed in an Oct. 9 letter that Dr. Agronin’s exemption meant he wasn’t required to sign a membership card or pay dues. “No fees will be taken from his paycheck, and he is not obligated to join the union,” said Redshaw. Agronin’s claim was based on Jewish law and beliefs that aligned against supporting the union.

CIR represents over 40,000 resident physicians, focusing on improving training and healthcare access. Redshaw accused CIR of channeling member dues into political causes unknown to new members, despite the union’s focus on improving pay and working conditions.

In May 2024, CIR passed resolutions titled “Housestaff for Human Rights” and “Housestaff Against Apartheid” regarding Israel. CIR stated the former prevented endorsing candidates supporting Israel, while the latter supported a ceasefire and cessation of aid to Israel.

Following Hamas attacks in October 2023, CIR expressed shock and mourned casualties from the ensuing violence. In its statement, the union urged restoration of basic needs in Gaza and a ceasefire but did not name Hamas, which Agronin noted in later testimony to the House Education and Workforce Committee.

Agronin pointed out that equating Israeli and Palestinian casualties in the statement implicitly equates attackers and victims. Redshaw suggested doctors with similar religious objections might also attain full union exemptions. Depending on state laws, these exemptions could cover total membership, not just fee redirection to charities.

CIR and Temple University Hospital have not responded to requests for comment. Rachel Wolf, a media and culture reporter, covered the incident for Fox News Digital.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *