Menu

Downstate Review: A Provocative Broadway Play

23 hours ago 0

The theater experience at the Booth Theatre begins almost innocuously. Familiar sights fill the stage: a couch, a kitchen, a dining table. Yet, a glance up from your Playbill reveals something unsettling — a TV showing an episode of ‘The Smurfs.’ These cheerful blue characters are pursued by Gargamel, their villainous foe. This oddity serves as a prelude to Bruce Norris’s play ‘Downstate,’ where main characters are convicted sex offenders, often seen as society’s real-life Gargamels.

‘Downstate’ opened to controversy four years ago at Playwrights Horizons and controversy hasn’t abated on Broadway, fueled largely by those who missed the production. Yet the play’s raw edge and fearlessness set it apart, making it one of the most compelling dramas seen on Broadway recently.

The play is set in downstate Illinois, where four distinct men live in a dilapidated apartment post-incarceration. Their crimes vary in severity, categorized from level one (low risk) to level three (high risk). Bruce Norris, known for ‘Clybourne Park,’ refrains from dictating audience opinion of these characters. Rather, he shifts perspectives, momentarily rendering these men relatable, only to expose their darker sides soon after.

The oldest residents are Fred, an elderly man in a motor scooter played by Francis Guinan, and Dee, portrayed by K. Todd Freeman, who is the outspoken realist of the group. Their personalities tend to humanize them, making their stories unsettling. Fred’s jolly demeanor reminds us of a Santa Claus figure. Dee’s humor causes mixed reactions as viewers find themselves laughing at his witticisms.

Gio, played by Al’Jaleel McGhee, is the only level one offender, after an encounter with a 17-year-old using a fake ID. Now, he works at an office supplies store, dreaming of entrepreneurship. His charm and smooth talk are captivating, though his after-hours interactions raise questions about his intentions. Felix, portrayed by Adrian Martinez, is a recluse who spends his time in prayer, adding a quiet intensity to the dynamic.

Their parole officer, Ivy, played by Liza Colón-Zayas, is at first perceived as harsh. However, a poignant scene with Felix reveals her as the voice of reason in a challenging environment.

A pivotal moment unfolds when Andy, one of Fred’s victims now in his 40s, visits with his wife. His quest for closure leads to unexpected and intense consequences. Thomas Sadoski’s portrayal of Andy is arresting, illustrating the deep psychological scars carried by victims.

The play’s longest-serving characters, Fred and Dee, bring unparalleled depth. Guinan and Freeman deliver performances that demand attention and highlight the complexity required by these roles. Freeman maintains a commanding presence, while Guinan utilizes his gentle appearance strategically.

Directed by Joe Mantello, each scene of ‘Downstate’ unfolds with unyielding intensity. The play challenges audiences with its bold content, blending humor with deeply unsettling themes. It’s a theatrical experience that provokes both reflection and conversation, examining individuals society often wishes to ignore.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *