Carlos Correa’s Potential Position Shift as Astros Eye Playoffs

Carlos Correa, once heralded as the top defensive player on the field, faces another potential position change. Now 31 years old, Correa has been sidelined since May due to an ankle injury. His return in the upcoming weeks could coincide with the Houston Astros’ push for an American League playoff spot, possibly seeing him at his third infield position this season.

While rehabilitating in Florida, Correa practiced at second base, as reported by MLB.com’s Brian McTaggart. Throughout his 12-year Major League Baseball career, Correa has never played at second base. He won the Platinum Glove at shortstop in 2021 and was moved to third base in the following season.

There is logic in keeping Isaac Paredes at third base and moving Jose Altuve off second base. Paredes has been Houston’s standout player this season, with a Wins Above Replacement (WAR) of 3.9 and 21 home runs by Monday. Conversely, Altuve has become one of the least effective defensive second basemen at age 36. Correa’s defensive skills surpass those of Paredes and Altuve at their current positions.

However, adjusting their lineup poses challenges. Shifting Altuve to designated hitter would push Yordan Alvarez into left field, where the slugger risks more physical strain and potential injuries.

Before contemplating their postseason lineup, the Astros must first secure playoff qualification. Competing for a playoff spot may require them to win the American League West, pitting them against the Texas Rangers. With no room for experimentation, the Astros need a plan for Correa that delivers immediate results. Failing which, Correa’s October might be spent watching the playoffs from home.