A judge granted permission for a former Cornell student, who sued Chi Phi fraternity members over rape accusations, to maintain the pseudonym “Jane Doe.” New York Supreme Court Justice Phaedra Perry-Bond ruled on Friday that publicizing Doe’s identity could lead to “retribution and retaliation,” impact her personal and professional life, and bring shame to her family. Doe expressed concerns about potential danger to her family and reported suffering from anxiety, depression, and insomnia.
The defendants did not object to Doe’s request for anonymity. The fraternity house involved in the case is located at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York.
Justice Perry-Bond prioritized Doe’s privacy over the usual practice of public court proceedings due to the notoriety of the allegations and reports of threats linked to the case. The judge issued a warning that harassment of anyone involved in the case could be a federal crime, leading to prosecution. She affirmed that Doe’s pseudonym keeps the case accessible to the public without needing to seal records or close sessions.
Despite Jane Doe’s anonymity, the defendants will remain named in court documents. Justice Perry-Bond also suggested extending protections for sensitive personal information to the defendants and invited all parties to propose an agreement for these safeguards.
Doe’s lawsuit, filed in September, accuses seven ex-members of Chi Phi fraternity of drugging and raping her on October 19, 2024. She also implicates the fraternity, the university, and a bar visited prior to the alleged assault. Her accusations describe becoming incapacitated by substances at the fraternity house. The accused men have denied the claims.
The fraternity was suspended on November 8, 2024, the same day Doe reported the assault to campus police. Initially, prosecutor Matthew Van Houten chose not to file charges, stating Doe’s November 2024 statement described her actions as “voluntary and consensual.” However, a later police interview showed Doe confidently declaring she was raped.
The ongoing investigation, reopened by Van Houten last month, diverges from Doe’s initial sworn statement. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul replaced Van Houten with Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor, citing doubts in Van Houten’s judgment. Her appointment has sparked controversy, with some defendants seeking her removal due to a perceived bias.
James defended her position in court, arguing that the governor’s appointment powers are valid. Another defendant requested James’s disqualification from grand jury proceedings, claiming her comments prejudiced the process, which remains unresolved.
