U.S. District Judge Michael J. Davis has mandated the immediate release of William Virgil Lizardo, a Canadian dentist, who was held by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) due to a mishandled notice. Lizardo, from Mississauga, Ontario, faced an erroneous detention after an immigration hearing notice was sent to an incorrect address, according to government records.
Davis, a Clinton appointee, ruled that Lizardo’s arrest violated the Fourth and Fifth Amendments, stressing the obvious risk of wrongful liberty deprivation. Davis criticized the lack of remedy offered by authorities, noting the appalling facts of the case. Lizardo’s release was ordered no later than 6 p.m. Sunday, with restrictions on further detention or removal without court approval.
Judicial disagreements with the Trump administration have surfaced repeatedly over ICE’s enforcement limits, especially concerning due process protections. DHS has criticized such rulings, accusing judges of overreaching their authority.
Lizardo entered the U.S. on an F-1 visa in 2019 for dental studies at the University of Minnesota. He graduated in 2023, married a U.S. citizen, and had a daughter in 2025. Despite his wife’s petition approval for him as a relative, Lizardo’s permanent residency application faced denial in January 2026 due to missing records for a dismissed legal charge from 2012.
Complications arose when DHS sent an incorrect hearing notice, leading to an unnotified removal order. Lizardo became aware of this during an October immigration interview, resulting in his arrest. After providing evidence for lack of notice, the immigration court rescinded the removal order and reopened his case.
Judge Davis rejected federal claims that argued for case dismissal, clarifying the lack of valid warrant or custody basis for Lizardo’s detention. Emphasizing Lizardo’s consistent compliance, Davis found no flight risk concerns. The judge granted Lizardo’s habeas corpus petition, ensured the return of his belongings, and restricted further detention without judicial approval.
Davis instructed any future detention requests require legal justification and evidence of changed circumstances. The government must prove that Lizardo’s release conditions cannot ensure his court appearance or community safety. Lizardo’s immigration status remains unresolved, as his proceedings continue post-ruling.

Former Reality Star Wins Lawsuit Over Workplace Harassment
NYC Mayor Disbands Controversial Police Unit
American Basketball Player Arrested in Nigeria for Drug Trafficking
Woman Charged After Alleged Assault on Horse Carriage Driver with Skateboard
Man Accused of Deceptive Acts as Veteran Faces Charges
ESPN Analyst Rex Ryan Faces Charges After Alleged Hit-and-Run