A Long Island man’s fabricated history as a decorated war hero has come under scrutiny. Facts emerged this week showing he was dishonorably discharged and allegedly stole $81,000 from a veterans’ group.
David Agtsteribbe, 58, is accused of falsely claiming a Purple Heart and presenting himself as a wounded veteran. Authorities arrested him two days before Veterans Day, the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office reported.
Agtsteribbe served for about a year in the military, ending with a discharge as a private in 1988. He faced a court-martial and admitted to stealing from another soldier in 1987.
Fraudulent Claims and Theft
Prosecutors assert that Agtsteribbe altered his discharge documents to showcase an honorable record. This deception allegedly led to a finance officer role in a local veterans’ group, where he misappropriated funds for personal use.
A fabricated military record is particularly shameful, especially when it involves stealing the achievements of others, according to District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney.
Tierney pointed out the betrayal of trust, stressing that veterans earned their honors through service, a trust Agtsteribbe is accused of abusing for personal gain.
Membership in Veterans Organization
In 2021, Agtsteribbe joined the Hampton Bays American Legion. He allegedly qualified through falsified discharge papers. Enhanced retirement status on these papers possibly offered perks like free health care.
Starting in 2022, he allegedly moved funds from the organization’s accounts to his own, covering expenses like Amazon purchases, bills, and leisure activities.
The accusations include a total theft of $81,798.31. His involvement with other veterans organizations since 2019, like the Military Order of the Purple Heart, further highlights his alleged deceit.
In recent years, he reportedly falsified documents to avoid fees and gain parking permits in Southampton.
Legal Consequences
Suffolk County DA Tierney emphasized the fraudulent nature of Agtsteribbe’s actions. In some instances, Agtsteribbe claimed to be a retired lieutenant colonel, while he was discharged as a private.
He faces multiple counts, including grand larceny and falsifying business records. If convicted, he could receive 25 years to life in prison due to prior felonies. Prosecutors propose a substantial bail, factoring in his history and current allegations.
Agtsteribbe is scheduled to appear in court on November 13, 2026.

Former Reality Star Wins Lawsuit Over Workplace Harassment
NYC Mayor Disbands Controversial Police Unit
American Basketball Player Arrested in Nigeria for Drug Trafficking
Woman Charged After Alleged Assault on Horse Carriage Driver with Skateboard
ESPN Analyst Rex Ryan Faces Charges After Alleged Hit-and-Run
Father Arrested After Infant Found Buried Alive