In 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Janus v. AFSCME that government employees are not obligated to support a union financially as a job requirement. This decision raised important questions about union practices. Two lawsuits today may push the court to reinforce their stance.
Oregon and New York have enacted laws with similar claims. They aim to prevent fraudulent impersonation of labor unions. Fraud, inherently illegal, allows no constitutional protection for deceiving workers. Yet, these laws target organizations like the Freedom Foundation. This group guides public employees on their right to opt out of union membership and financial obligations.
Oregon’s law forbids impersonation of union representatives, setting statutory damages at $6,250 for each occurrence. The Freedom Foundation contested this law in court, insisting that it hampers protected speech. After an initial ruling against them, the organization sought an appeal from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
New York introduced Civil Service Law Section 216, empowering the Attorney General to act upon suspicion of misleading communications with fines of $1,000 per incident. The Freedom Foundation filed a lawsuit against New York on September 28.
These laws present preemptive challenges rather than merely addressing prosecuted cases. No proof was provided against the Freedom Foundation’s intent to mislead. Yet, these laws make organizations reconsider their communications, fearing them later interpreted as deceitful.
This situation circles back to Janus. Since 2018, unions and their political partners have developed strategies to complicate union membership opt-out processes. The Freedom Foundation has defended many workers severing union ties and repeatedly called on the Supreme Court to intervene in these disputes. However, the court has declined each appeal.
The restraint has encouraged tests on the court’s boundaries. The laws in Oregon and New York show the next logical step. Suppressing vital information makes it legally risky to inform employees of their rights and choices.
The Janus ruling didn’t focus on fraud, which is tackled by existing legal means when harm occurs. State threats of fraud under broad laws serve as convenient suppression tools. Authorities shouldn’t impose massive penalties based on abstract, politically driven enforcement.
The Freedom Foundation’s challenges to these laws in federal court might reach the Supreme Court. If so, the justices could clarify their stance against governmental intimidation regarding employee rights. Since Janus, the court has mostly observed, as unions expanded their reach. It’s time to halt such overreach. A right disrupted by fear or bureaucracy is ineffective.
Jeff Rhodes serves as vice president of news and information at the Freedom Foundation.
Copyright 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material cannot be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller