On August 20, the United States deported more than 160 individuals to Haiti. This marked the first removal flight since ending temporary protected status (TPS) for around 350,000 Haitians. The flight landed in Cap-Haïtien instead of Port-au-Prince due to security concerns making the capital’s airport unsafe for U.S. flights.
TPS permits eligible foreign nationals in the U.S. to stay and work legally when their home country is considered unsafe. Haiti received TPS designation following the 2010 earthquake, which took over 220,000 lives and displaced 1.5 million people. For 15 years, U.S. administrations renewed or redesigned TPS for Haiti. However, in June, a Supreme Court decision concluded a legal battle, resulting in the loss of this protection for Haitians.
Debate surrounds the 15-year TPS duration, with both advocates and critics using it to support their arguments. A critical question arises: What actions are appropriate when disasters turn chronic?
My parents moved from Haiti to the U.S. in the 1980s, not under TPS. Their experience, coupled with my work, emphasizes that migration often starts long before visible disasters. I manage network development at Meta, focusing on resilience and system capacity. Networks should withstand failures and reroute efficiently. Incomplete recoveries increase vulnerabilities, risking permanent capacity loss without proper investment.
“Between 2008 and 2023, 44 natural disasters caused approximately 2.9 million internal displacements in Haiti, out of a population of about 10 million,” according to the Internal Displacement Monitoring Center.
Haiti faces continuous recovery challenges with successive governments dealing with instability, elite control, and underinvestment. By the mid-2010s, around 80% of urban households relied on charcoal, raising wood demand and prompting urban migration. Cities lacked sufficient jobs, housing, and public services.
These patterns appear worldwide as climate change enhances existing stresses. The U.S. approach of temporary TPS renewals based on current assessments is insufficient. Establishing a formal process for prolonged national crises is necessary. I propose a national stability review by the Departments of Homeland Security and State, triggered after 10 years of a country’s TPS designation.
The review, with published findings, would differ from current Homeland Security assessments. It would determine if conditions indicate a chronic crisis, considering severity and durability of issues, compounded environmental factors, return feasibility, and institutional support for returnees.
If a chronic situation is identified, a second stage would assess individuals with a continuous 10-year TPS history. Only those with significant ties to the U.S. could apply for permanent residence, subject to screening. This method targets long-standing TPS holders rooted in the U.S., ensuring thoughtful relief matching the issue.
Although Congress has enacted permanent relief for specific groups, such measures are often nationality-specific with set conditions. A national stability review would evaluate TPS suitability in prolonged crises. The U.S. cannot offer permanent residency to millions facing environmental weak governance and poor infrastructure. A review wouldn’t guarantee new migrants or automatic status changes; it would prevent indefinite protection renewals and sudden reversals.
Fifteen years of TPS reflects not only political inaction but also the illogical nature of calling some crises temporary. Events like earthquakes or hurricanes end, but systemic failures persist where basic functions like airport landings are jeopardized. Congress should distinguish acute emergencies from chronic fragility and provide a nuanced humanitarian approach.
Alex-Handrah Aimé, Vice President of Network Investments at Meta, was born in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, and is a PD Soros Fellow and a 2026 Public Voices Fellow with the OpEd Project.

NFL’s Attempts at Embracing Diversity Through Spanish Feels Forced
Editorial Board’s Take on California’s Housing Decisions
Stephen A. Smith Discusses Trump’s Midterm Losses and Political Climate
The Evolving Landscape of Modern Love
Critiques and Praise for Minnesota Leadership
Regional Government Success: Portland vs. Twin Cities