Menu

Examining the Role of Schools in Equalizing Educational Opportunities

2 weeks ago 0

In 1848, Horace Mann described public schooling as a “great equalizer of the conditions of men.” More than 175 years later, the debate continues among education scholars about the validity of this assertion. Some research suggests that a child’s family background has a more significant impact on academic achievement than schools. Other studies indicate that schools can narrow achievement gaps which might otherwise be greater.

A classic study from the 1980s in Baltimore revealed that low-income and wealthier children learned at similar rates during the school year. Achievement gaps widened during summer due to factors such as access to books, libraries, and camps. The extent of summer learning loss remains uncertain. However, the initial gaps in reading and math skills between rich and poor children are apparent from the first day of kindergarten, influenced by elements beyond K-12 education. These gaps typically remain constant throughout the school years.

I am an education policy scholar focusing on various factors influencing student learning, such as teachers and their instruction quality. My colleagues and I moved beyond measuring student learning at school. We evaluated what students receive both in and out of school: funding, support services, and family time. Schools can act as equalizers for children from different backgrounds, yet the effect has limitations.

A gap that starts early in childhood

Our 2026 study used data from 10 national surveys to track 77 investments, including teachers, tutoring, housing, food, and childcare. We assessed both direct costs and intangible factors, such as parents’ reading time with their children. We assigned a monetary value to each element for comparison. On average, a U.S. child receives about $502,000 in investments from birth to age 18.

Significant differences in these investments emerge early. By age five, children from the poorest quarter of families receive $44,000 less than those from the richest quarter, representing a 24% gap, primarily drawn from housing and childcare disparities. A notable shift occurs when children enter elementary school. The investment gap narrows to 12%. For Black children, the disparity reduces from 20% to 7% as kindergarten begins. These reductions align with studies showing increased school funding improves outcomes, especially for low-income students.

Why don’t achievement gaps close during school years?

Part of the issue lies in how resources are used. Our research shows that low-income families receive more tutoring and special education services than higher-income families. Black children receive significant tutoring as well. While these services are designed to help students catch up, they are not equivalent to resources that help others get ahead.

Tutoring has been a key method for helping students improve. Since the pandemic, tutoring has become increasingly common, with schools receiving nearly $190 billion in relief funds. More than a third of public schools offered frequent, small-group tutoring by 2022-23. Schools with higher numbers of low-income and students of color prioritized this service. However, for many low-income, Black, and Latino students, tutoring was already a norm. Among school-age children from 2014 to 2021, approximately 17% received tutoring. Black children at 25% and Latino children at 19% surpassed the 14% of white children receiving tutoring.

Early pandemic recovery data indicates little growth in tutoring. A 2022 parent survey revealed about 15% of students were tutored. Despite federal money aiding recovery, achievement gaps remain wider than before the pandemic.

Who gets ahead

While efforts focus on catching up, wealthier children benefit from additional resources. Some studies suggest low-income and minority students often have less experienced teachers, a pattern confirmed in our study. Beyond education, affluent families invest more in music lessons, sports, and activities that provide educational advantages.

By 2024, the wealthiest 10% of families spent over 13 times more on childcare, education, and extracurriculars compared to the poorest quartile, a sharp increase from the early 1980s.

Equal spending isn’t enough

Our findings indicate public education reduces the investment gap between rich and poor children. However, equal spending doesn’t equate to equal opportunity. Much of the extra funding for low-income, Black, and Latino children addresses pre-school gaps. Meanwhile, wealthier children continue to benefit from the resources that help them excel.

To truly close these gaps, education needs to provide more than just catch-up assistance. Students need the same opportunities that allow wealthier peers to advance. Since significant gaps develop before kindergarten in areas such as housing and childcare, expanding support beyond schools is necessary.

David Blazar, Malen Professor for Urban Education Policy, University of Maryland

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *