The 2026 college football season witnessed one of its standout victories when BYU Cougars defeated the Notre Dame Fighting Irish in Provo. This win significantly boosted BYU’s reputation and showcased the Big 12 Conference’s national relevancy. It positioned BYU as a potential College Football Playoff contender and established them as a top-10 team. However, a setback occurred when BYU lost to a middling UCF team in Florida, slightly diminishing the anticipation for their game against the Utah Utes on November 7.
The much-anticipated “Holy War” between BYU and Utah displayed the teams’ high caliber. Despite Utah winning 28-20, the rivalry was an intense and evenly matched contest. The victory further solidified a major win for the Big 12 Conference.
Utah’s Ascendancy
The Utah Utes’ stunning comeback victory catapulted them to No. 2 in the AP Top 25 Poll, trailing only the Georgia Bulldogs. With an undefeated record of 9-0 in the Power 4 conference, their wins include a notable victory over a top-15 Houston Cougars team besides BYU. Currently, they are strong favorites for the playoff and the Big 12 Conference title, likely earning a first-round bye. Utah’s credentials as National Championship contenders remain substantial.
Criticism and Skepticism
Despite the Utes’ success, ESPN’s senior analyst Heather Didich expressed skepticism about their title chances. On ESPN’s “Get Up” show, she downplayed Utah’s ranking, attributing it to other teams’ losses. Didich highlighted doubts about Utah’s capability, citing their narrow win against Colorado and suggesting potential weaknesses in title contention.
BYU’s performance against Utah was also scrutinized, with Didich pointing to mistakes by quarterback Bear Bachmeier as factors in the game’s outcome. Paul Finebaum offered a definitive stance, doubting Utah’s ability to win the championship.
Comparisons and Context
Comparisons between Utah and Georgia have emerged. While Georgia endured a home loss to Auburn, Utah maintained a perfect record. Critics often overlook such developments and continue to view Utah’s accomplishments skeptically. According to ESPN’s SP+, Utah ranks just one spot below Alabama, illustrating their status as a legitimate contender.
The rankings indicate that if Alabama, ranked eighth, is considered a championship threat, Utah, at ninth, deserves similar recognition. Furthermore, Texas ranks sixth with only a marginal advantage over Utah. Such comparisons underscore the Utes’ potential to compete closely with top-tier teams.
In conclusion, while future outcomes remain uncertain, the bias against Utah is noteworthy. With ESPN likely elevating their status if circumstances were different, Utah still stands as a formidable force in college football.

Challenges Facing US Soccer: Insights from Mauricio Pochettino
Giants’ Historic 2008 Upset Gets Spotlight in New Netflix Documentary
AEW’s Blood and Guts: A Glimpse into the Brutal Spectacle
Nationals Retain Jacob Young with Four-Year Contract
TNA Destination X: A Night of High Stakes and Intense Matches
Kenneth Walker’s Injury and Impact on Kansas City Chiefs