The NFL trade deadline passed on Tuesday afternoon, leaving the Indianapolis Colts in a familiar place: underperformance. Despite several trade offers for running back Jonathan Taylor—including ones with multiple high draft picks—the Colts opted not to trade him, holding out for a blockbuster deal that never materialized.
The Colts, despite engaging in discussions with teams like the Minnesota Vikings about players like Daniel Jones, decided to keep their starting quarterback. On the receiver front, the Colts did make moves, trading Josh Downs and Keenan Allen. Downs was sent to the Kansas City Chiefs for a fourth- and fifth-round pick, while Allen went to the San Francisco 49ers for a sixth-round pick in 2027.
These trades made sense, especially since Downs had requested a trade, and Allen, at 34, is on the final year of his contract. However, the lack of a trade for Taylor has sparked discussions. The Colts had a potential trade offer from the New York Giants that included a second- and fifth-round pick but turned it down, seeking a higher pick—ideally a first-rounder.
The Colts’ indecision extended to other players, as they held onto starting defensive tackle Grover Stewart despite offers that increased from a fifth-round to a fourth-round pick and an additional late-round pick. These offers were eventually rescinded as the Colts waited for better deals.
Critics are questioning the Colts’ strategy, with some suggesting that the team might regret not using these trade opportunities to build future draft capital. The reasoning, according to sources, was to maintain the team’s appeal for a future general manager or head coach if there are changes at the end of the season.
This approach may be flawed, as incoming leadership could prefer more draft picks to shape the team according to their vision. Additionally, Taylor’s disappointment in staying with a struggling team rather than joining a playoff contender could have broader implications. The Colts, struggling with a 2-7 record, seem to be continuing a pattern of disappointment both on the field and off.

Challenges Facing US Soccer: Insights from Mauricio Pochettino
Giants’ Historic 2008 Upset Gets Spotlight in New Netflix Documentary
AEW’s Blood and Guts: A Glimpse into the Brutal Spectacle
Nationals Retain Jacob Young with Four-Year Contract
TNA Destination X: A Night of High Stakes and Intense Matches
Kenneth Walker’s Injury and Impact on Kansas City Chiefs