An Alaska judge decided on Wednesday that the campaign request by Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola for a list of absentee voters with rejected ballots is unreasonable. This decision comes amidst the ongoing vote count from last week’s election.
The election involves a ranked voting system with Peltola and Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan as the main competitors. Alaska’s Senate race remains the only undecided race in the nation. The state accepts overseas ballots up to 15 days after the general election, with November 18 marking the final day for receipt. This date also serves as the deadline for the Division of Elections to conduct the ranked vote tabulations if needed. This will happen if no candidate secures more than 50% of the first-choice votes.
Peltola’s campaign filed a lawsuit through their attorneys against state election officials last Friday. They sought a list of voters whose absentee ballots were rejected and the reasons for these rejections. Their intent was to ensure the votes of all qualified voters are counted.
The state opposed the request, arguing it would breach voter privacy. Officials claimed that generating such a list from the voter database equates to an “electronic service or product”, which state law does not prioritize over the agency’s essential duties.
Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews ruled that, theoretically, the voter database records could be redacted and shared. However, he stated that the division need not disclose the records as they cannot be reasonably produced in the current situation without confidential information. He explained that the division is preoccupied with its primary responsibility, which is administrating elections.
Matthews noted that the timing of the campaign’s request was inconvenient. An email requesting comments from one of Peltola’s representing law firms was unreturned on Wednesday, which was a holiday. The state Department of Law, backing the Division of Elections, expressed satisfaction with Matthews’ ruling.
During arguments, Abha Khanna, representing Peltola’s campaign, stated that the campaign did not intend to disrupt the counting process. Khanna mentioned that the absentee ballot review was proceeding smoothly. But, she argued that the information sought is public record, similar to what campaign observers can access where absentee review boards gather. The campaign aimed to access this information more centrally.
State attorneys contended that reports generated by the division, listing ballots under review, are not public records. These documents are considered confidential and are temporary working documents not maintained for preservation.
Michaela Thompson, overseeing the absentee ballot review boards, confirmed in an affidavit that the report version available to observers—campaign-affiliated included—lacks some confidential details yet contains home addresses many wish to keep private. Observers sign confidentiality agreements prohibiting them from keeping, copying, or recording report information.
Thompson further explained the division’s outdated database cannot generate a report that omits confidential addresses. Collaborating with a vendor would be necessary to create a customized report, if needed.

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller