Joseph Gerth, a columnist for the Louisville Courier Journal, recently penned a pre-obituary for Senator Mitch McConnell. The column accuses McConnell, a former Republican Majority Leader, of undoing civil rights protections he once supported and enabling President Donald Trump despite privately disparaging him as ‘stupid’ and a ‘despicable human being.’
Gerth wrote this piece to offer his perspective on McConnell’s career while the senator is still alive, reasoning that nobody could accuse him of disrespecting a deceased individual. This idea was inspired by the backlash against criticisms of South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham following his death on July 11.
In the article, Gerth compared McConnell to former President Richard Nixon, labeling him as similarly detestable but noting McConnell avoided accountability. He highlighted McConnell’s 2016 move to block President Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court, citing voters should decide the appointment during an election year before confirming Amy Coney Barrett just days before the 2020 presidential vote.
McConnell’s actions, Gerth argued, eroded the court’s credibility, evidenced by the court’s approval dropping from 58 percent in July 2020 to 36 percent in a recent Economist/YouGov survey.
Concerns About McConnell’s Health
McConnell’s extended absence from public life has fueled speculation about his health and prompted calls for changes in health disclosure for Congress members. He has not attended any Senate roll call votes since June 11, according to GovTrack.us. His office released a hospital photo mid-July, linking his absence to a fall and pneumonia. However, doubts about his health linger.
McConnell has endured multiple falls and health scares in recent years, raising questions about his condition.
Mitch McConnell’s Congressional Career
McConnell entered the Senate in 1984 by defeating an incumbent Democrat, marking the first Republican statewide victory in Kentucky since 1968. He secured reelection six times, becoming the state’s longest-serving senator.
His earlier political career differed from his Washington legacy. McConnell attended civil rights rallies and interned for Republican Senator John Sherman Cooper. Reflecting on President Lyndon Johnson signing the Voting Rights Act, McConnell described it as an overwhelming moment.
Throughout decades in Washington, McConnell grew into a leading Republican figure, navigating between majority and minority leader roles as Senate control shifted. His tenure saw significant legislative achievements, including assisting with Trump’s 2017 tax reform and sponsoring 31 bills that became law.
McConnell’s rapport with Trump was intricate. Despite endorsing Trump’s agenda and confirming three Supreme Court nominees, their relationship strained post-2020 election. McConnell acknowledged Biden’s victory and faulted Trump for the January 6 Capitol riot but did not vote to convict following Trump’s second impeachment. Even amid Trump’s attacks, McConnell backed Trump’s 2024 bid. McConnell announced he would not seek another Senate term on his 83rd birthday.
Introduction of Health Disclosure Legislation
The prolonged absence of McConnell and other lawmakers has sparked discussions on enforcing health disclosure rules in Congress. On July 14, Democratic Representative Ritchie Torres proposed legislation requiring Congress members to issue a public notice explaining extended voting absences.
The Duty of Transparency Act would mandate members inform constituents about anticipated absence duration and their ability to perform duties during this time. Current rules do not obligate health-related disclosures or voting absence explanations.
While some members voluntarily share updates, like Senator John Fetterman during his hospitalization for depression, these disclosures are not standard.
Scrutiny of Senators’ Ages
McConnell’s hospitalization and Graham’s sudden passing have intensified scrutiny over Congress’s aging upper chamber, where the average age is now 65, and over a third are 70 or older. These events spotlight the enduring tenure of lawmakers into their 80s and 90s.
According to Newsweek’s analysis, with an average age of 65.1 and median age of 66, 36 senators are 70 or older, eight are 80 or older, with Chuck Grassley, the 92-year-old Iowa Republican, being the oldest. Grassley, third in presidential succession as Senate president pro tempore, maintains his office fitness with his continual corn farming activities.
The Senate’s age composition is varied: eight members are in their 40s, 22 in their 50s, 33 in their 60s, 28 in their 70s, seven in their 80s, and Grassley is the lone nonagenarian.
Both parties are nearly age-equivalent, with Republicans averaging 64.9 years among 52 senators, while Democrats have a 64.6 average across 45 senators. However, the age discrepancy widens among older senators where Republicans hold 17 seats in their 70s compared to 11 Democrats.
List of Senators Over 70
- Sheldon Whitehouse, 70, Democrat, Rhode Island
- Chuck Grassley, 92, Republican, Iowa
- Bernie Sanders, 84, independent, Vermont
- Mitch McConnell, 84, Republican, Kentucky
- James E. Risch, 83, Republican, Idaho
- Angus S. King, Jr., 82, independent, Maine
- Richard J. Durbin, 81, Democrat, Illinois
- Richard Blumenthal, 80, Democrat, Connecticut
- Edward J. Markey, 80, Democrat, Massachusetts
- Jeanne Shaheen, 79, Democrat, New Hampshire
- Peter Welch, 79, Democrat, Vermont
- Mazie K. Hirono, 78, Democrat, Hawaii
- Ron Wyden, 77, Democrat, Oregon
- Elizabeth Warren, 77, Democrat, Massachusetts
- Jack Reed, 76, Democrat, Rhode Island
- Roger F. Wicker, 75, Republican, Mississippi
- John Boozman, 75, Republican, Arkansas
- Mike Crapo, 75, Republican, Idaho
- Patty Murray, 75, Democrat, Washington
- Charles E. Schumer, 75, Democrat, New York
- Deb Fischer, 75, Republican, Nebraska
- James C. Justice, 75, Republican, West Virginia
- John Cornyn, 74, Republican, Texas
- Marsha Blackburn, 74, Republican, Tennessee
- John Kennedy, 74, Republican, Louisiana
- John W. Hickenlooper, 74, Democrat, Colorado
- John Barrasso, 73, Republican, Wyoming
- Susan M. Collins, 73, Republican, Maine
- Rick Scott, 73, Republican, Florida
- Shelley Moore Capito, 72, Republican, West Virginia
- Jerry Moran, 72, Republican, Kansas
- Mark R. Warner, 71, Democrat, Virginia
- Ron Johnson, 71, Republican, Wisconsin
- Mike Rounds, 71, Republican, South Dakota
- Cynthia M. Lummis, 71, Republican, Wyoming
- Tommy Tuberville, 71, Republican, Alabama
Contact Newsweek editors for further information: Jason Lemon, Edward Pearcey, and Geoffrey Rowland.

Trump Administration Appeals to Supreme Court Over White House Ballroom Construction
Controversy Surrounds ICE’s New Pain Gloves
France’s Constitutional Council Rejects Social Media Ban for Children Under 15
The Complex Influence of Time in Human Society
Trump Administration’s Noncitizen Voter Fraud Investigation Yields Sparse Results
TruP Border Wall Construction: Controversy and Facts