Menu

Close Senate Races Lead to Legal Battles in Alaska and Mississippi

1 week ago 0

Days after November 3, the Alaska Senate race remains unresolved, with Democrat Mary Peltola’s campaign filing a lawsuit against state election officials on Friday. The suit seeks immediate access to information regarding absentee ballots that were rejected during the closely contested election. Peltola’s campaign argues that such disclosure is vital to ensure all eligible votes are counted and to uphold the integrity of the race, which has seen significant challenges due to a namesake contender for Republican Senator Dan Sullivan. Last month, the Justice Department sued Alaska election officials, seeking to prevent certification of the results if Sullivan lost and votes for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. might have influenced the outcome. This lawsuit was dismissed by a state judge just before Election Day.

As the race remains exceptionally tight, with about 600 votes separating Peltola and Sullivan, even a few ballots could determine the result. Alaska will continue to accept overseas voters’ ballots until November 18.

Meanwhile, in Mississippi, another close Senate race, Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith is preparing for potential legal actions. Her campaign requests that provisional ballots be set aside for scrutiny. “These measures are necessary to verify the eligibility of affidavit ballots for counting,” stated a letter from her legal team, Lex Political, sent to Mississippi election officials.

In a separate case in California, the Trump administration dropped a lawsuit against the state over an estimated 20,000 mail-in ballots. These were cast by individuals suspected of being non-U.S. citizens. California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced the dismissal as a victory for the state following several legal setbacks for the federal government.

Mary Peltola’s Lawsuit Details

Peltola’s campaign group, Alaskans for Mary, filed a lawsuit against the Alaska Division of Elections as well as Lieutenant Governor Nancy Dahlstrom and Director of Elections Carol Beecher. They demand records revealing which absentee ballots were rejected and the reasons for these rejections. “Plaintiff cannot ensure that its voters’ lawful votes were properly counted without knowing whose absentee ballots were rejected or questioned, and why,” states the filed document.

The campaign previously requested these records on October 27, without receiving a response. On November 4, it reiterated its demand for the records by 4:00 p.m. the following day. The request was declined through a phone call and subsequent email correspondence, the lawsuit claims.

Without access to the records, Peltola’s campaign is unable to confirm if ballots were correctly tallied or if votes for Peltola were unjustly rejected. As the counting and review of absentee ballots progress alongside approaching certification deadlines, the campaign argues that each delay in providing the requested records hampers their ability to ensure that every valid vote counts.

State Denial of Access

In response, the state Department of Law, representing the lieutenant governor and the Division of Elections, explained the denial of access was due to the confidential nature of these records. “Because the information is preliminary and not yet available to affected voters, the Division does not release these records separately or allow observers to retain them,” the department stated. Preliminary release could burden the processing and delay vote counting. The Division has consistently protected such information and intends to ask the court to uphold this confidentiality.

Contacted for comments on Saturday morning were Alaska’s Department of Law, and Peltola’s and Sullivan’s campaigns.

Mary Peltola vs. Dan Sullivan: Current Status

As of Saturday morning, over 20% of votes remain uncounted. Peltola, an Alaska native and former congresswoman, holds a slight lead over Republican Senator Dan Sullivan, with 48.2% to 47.9% of the vote. Two other candidates, Republican Gerald Heikes and undeclared Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., have received 2.3% and 1.7% of the votes, respectively. Sullivan Jr. switched to undeclared amid accusations of being a fake candidate intended to divert votes from the incumbent.

Final results may not be available for several days. In a probable scenario where neither Sullivan nor Peltola achieves a majority, ranked choice tabulation will occur fifteen days after the election.

Cindy Hyde-Smith vs. Scott Colom: Current Status

In Mississippi, Republican Hyde-Smith trails Democrat Scott Colom by nearly 2,000 votes. With 97% of the votes counted, Hyde-Smith has 48.8%, while Colom leads with 49.1%. Independent candidate Ty Pinkins garnered 2.1% of votes. If Colom succeeds, he would become the first Black senator from Mississippi since the Reconstruction era. Hyde-Smith was initially appointed and later won a 2018 special election.

The Mississippi Senate race result is expected before Alaska’s. Unlike Alaska, Mississippi does not require a runoff election even if candidates do not reach 50% of the votes. Hyde-Smith’s legal team asked election officials to separate and document affidavit ballots for potential legal review. This request emphasizes preserving all voting records for any future legal proceedings.

Communications were solicited from Hyde-Smith’s and Colom’s campaigns on Saturday morning.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *