Is Lamar Jackson No Longer a Top 10 Quarterback?

Questions have arisen about Lamar Jackson’s status among the elite quarterbacks in the NFL. An ESPN survey of executives, coaches, and scouts suggests that some view Jackson as outside the top 10. Colin Cowherd of Fox Sports Radio shares this sentiment.

Cowherd expressed doubts about Jackson’s performance under pressure. He stated, “I no longer trust Lamar Jackson in a big spot.” Cowherd indicated he would prefer Bo Nix over Jackson in a critical fourth-quarter situation.

“I no longer trust Lamar Jackson in a big spot. I’m selling my stock.” — Colin Cowherd

Cowherd’s list of top quarterbacks includes:

• Josh Allen (Bills)
• Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs)
• Caleb Williams (Bears)
• Matthew Stafford (Rams)
• Justin Herbert (Chargers)
• Joe Burrow (Bengals)
• Sam Darnold (Seahawks)
• Jared Goff (Lions)
• Jordan Love (Packers)
• Drake Maye (Patriots)

On the surface, excluding Jackson from the top 10 might seem like a provocative stance. Arguments have positioned Jackson alongside Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes in the past. However, opinions about his ranking vary widely.

Jackson has been one of the league’s top quarterbacks over seven seasons, winning two MVP awards. His odds for another MVP run this year are strong compared to quarterbacks ranked ahead of him by Cowherd.

Yet, there is a counterargument. Jackson’s performance has not consistently matched his previous high level. Last season, Jackson was not among the top 10 quarterbacks. He averaged 196.1 passing yards per game, fewer than Michael Penix Jr. and Geno Smith. His projected season totals were league average for touchdowns, and he was less effective rushing.

Some reasons could include injuries or Jackson not being fully healthy. If true, he might regain his MVP form. However, early declines are possible, as evidenced by Russell Wilson’s and Cam Newton’s examples.

Jackson’s athleticism has been central to his success, but quarterbacks reliant on athleticism often age differently compared to those who excel in pocket passing.

Jackson’s postseason performance remains a concern despite regular-season dominance. His playoff record is 3-5, with a 60.6% completion rate and an 84.6 passer rating. In clutch situations, Cowherd prefers other quarterbacks.

Cowherd cited Jackson’s lack of success in critical moments as a factor in his assessment. If evaluating quarterbacks based on clutch performances, leaving Jackson out of the top 10 is plausible.

Jackson enters the 2026 season with uncertainties. Issues about his health, athletic decline, coaching adaptation, and commitment arise frequently.

Many top quarterbacks like Mahomes and Allen are viewed as safer options. Jackson’s comparison with names like Jordan Love and Jared Goff remains open for debate.

Questioning whether Jackson is a top-10 quarterback is valid until he proves reliable in key situations.