The controversy surrounding two Dan Sullivans on the ballot in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race is reminiscent of Florida’s 2020 state Senate election. In Alaska, allegations linger over potential “ballot stacking” involving similar candidate names. This strategy is generally legal and more common in U.S. elections than assumed.
The Alaska Case: Two Dan Sullivans
According to Alaska’s ranked choice voting system, the top four candidates from the primary will appear on the ballot. They include: Mary Peltola, a Democrat; incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan; Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher who originally filed as a Republican; and Gerald “Jerry” Heikes, running as a Republican.
President Trump criticized the presence of a second Dan Sullivan, accusing Democrats of “cheating”. The Alaska election authority ruled Sullivan Jr. wasn’t a genuine candidate but reinstated him after court decisions. Trump’s administration filed a lawsuit to challenge election results if votes for Sullivan Jr. impacted Sullivan’s victory.
The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) filed a motion to dismiss the suit, claiming it aimed to undermine Alaska’s election results without legal basis. Allegations surfaced that Democrats sought to stack the ballot with another candidate named Sullivan. Elisa Rios, former campaign manager for Peltola, stated efforts to recruit Sullivan Jr. were made. Peltola denied involvement or knowledge of such efforts.
A federal judge dismissed Trump’s lawsuit, ruling that the proposed measures didn’t resolve voter confusion concerns. Though described as meritless, experts acknowledged valid concerns about potential voter confusion, emphasized by Michael Morley from Florida State University.
Investigation and Legal Challenges
Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy remains under investigation by the Justice Department and Alaska’s Governor Mike Dunleavy. Despite allegations of legal wrongdoing, “ballot stacking” is typically legal unless incentives like payments are proven.
Newsweek reporters contacted Sullivan and Peltola campaigns for comments amidst ongoing investigations.
Florida’s 2020 Senate Ballot Drama
In Florida’s 2020 state Senate race, the ballot included two Rodriguez candidates: Democratic incumbent Jose Javier Rodriguez and Alex Rodriguez, running as an independent with no party affiliation. Ileana Garcia, a Republican, narrowly defeated Rodriguez with assistance from a sham candidate.
Frank Artiles, a former Republican state senator, was charged with paying for the sham candidacy to confuse voters. Artiles eventually received probation and jail time for election conspiracy.
Jose Javier Rodriguez is now on the ballot for Florida Attorney General. Despite controversy, Ileana Garcia was reelected and remains a strong voice against Trump’s immigration policies.
Lessons from Florida for Alaska
Artiles was convicted of illegal campaign contributions, not of appointing a sham candidate, highlighting that payment constitutes a legal violation. In Alaska, allegations of payment surrounding Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy haven’t emerged.
U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche accused the election of fraud, while Trump echoed these sentiments. Election officials clarified voter differentiation for the two Dan Sullivans to mitigate confusion.
FairVote confirmed Alaska’s ranked choice voting system reduces fear of split votes between candidates sharing names. They suggest ranking both Dan Sullivans to ensure the stronger candidate prevails.

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller