Following a lengthy hike leading up to the 2024 election, I shared a beer with seasoned journalist Jim Rainey, who was reporting on the race between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump. Polls indicated a close contest, bad news for Harris, reminiscent of 2016 when polls favored Hillary Clinton yet ended unexpectedly.
Sitting at the Mt. Baldy Lodge, Jim recounted discussions with pollsters about the 2016 election results. They claimed to have new methods to include underrepresented conservatives who distrust traditional polls. They assured this election would be different. That assurance lingered as we continued our conversation.
Ultimately, Harris suffered a significant defeat, losing popular votes by millions and in all battleground states.
Shift from Polls to Betting Platforms
Approaching the upcoming midterms, declining reliance on traditional polls has emerged, replaced by an interest in betting odds. Online platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket changed how elections are followed in the U.S. While known for sports and cryptocurrency bets, these sites now attract huge audiences betting on democratic outcomes.
Betting on midterms reached $1.4 billion across major prediction markets. People are wagering on outcomes, voter turnout, and candidate rhetoric.
Predictive Power of Gamblers
Checking Kalshi showed $65 million in bets on Congress control, with a 66% chance of a Democratic sweep, and $107 million on the Los Angeles mayoral race, favoring Karen Bass at 57%.
Betting extends beyond immediate elections. Nearly $250 million has been bet on the 2028 Democratic presidential nominee, with Gavin Newsom leading slightly over contenders.
Efforts to determine if gamblers outpredict traditional pollsters have proven inconclusive. Betting markets offer real-time adjustments based on polling, news, and social media influences. Participants bet based on financial stakes rather than hopeful outcomes.
Concerns About Prediction Markets
However, prediction markets primarily attract young, tech-savvy male bettors, leading to skewed representations. Additionally, concerns about the integrity arise; they function like virtual casinos.
A significant wager can drastically alter odds in smaller races. Previously, Kalshi suspended candidates for betting on their contests. While individual suspensions occur, coordinated group influencing remains problematic.
A broader question persists: is gambling on the fate of democracy wise?

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller