On the night of February 25, 2023, Blaise Taylor found himself outside Vanderbilt Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee. He was questioned by police following a date night that became a medical emergency.
Blaise Taylor (Police Bodycam): We were together having a date night.
Authorities sought clarity on the condition of 24-year-old Jade Benning who arrived at the hospital unresponsive. Taylor told officers during the bodycam footage that Benning began feeling unwell.
Taylor had invited Benning, a professional chef, to her apartment for a dinner she had planned as a special night aimed at strengthening their relationship.
The evening turned harrowing when Benning suddenly became ill, spitting up and shaking. Unsure of how to help, Taylor first reached out to his father. His father, a college football coach often relied upon for medical advice within the family, advised Blaise to immediately call 911.
Blaise Taylor (911 Call): I don’t know what’s happening. She’s got spit coming out of her mouth and she’s shaking.
First responders discovered Benning on her bed without a pulse and transported her to the hospital. Nijaiha Jackson, Benning’s best friend, had returned to Benning’s apartment only to be met with distressing news.
Nijaiha Jackson: She has to be OK. I just saw her an hour ago.
Considered lively by her family and friends, Benning had been vibrant and sociable, known for her leadership as a cheerleading captain in Little Rock, Arkansas.
Her life took her from Little Rock to Nashville, chasing a culinary dream and a restaurant ownership ambition. Benning’s father, Dennis Browning, noted her role as a unifier, particularly evident after the separation of her parents.
Browning reflected on how Benning always tried to keep the peace between family members.
When her parents learned about Taylor, they understood his local fame in Arkansas for his college football career. Taylor, having once earned standout awards and a college scholarship, was seen by his family as a community-focused individual involved in educational initiatives for children.
Jade and Blaise’s relationship was initially casual, but took a serious turn in November 2022 with news of Benning’s pregnancy. She shared the imminent prospect of becoming a parent with her parents, including the father’s identity.
Benning and Taylor’s relationship fluctuated, but they rekindled, looking forward to welcoming a daughter, Ivy. Paintings from their date-night were meant for Ivy’s room.
However, hope turned to horror when Jackson received a call from Benning. According to Jackson, Benning accused Taylor of drugging her drink during the call. The conversation lasted six minutes before disconnecting.
Nijaiha Jackson: It just sounded like something I never heard before.
Once at the hospital, Jackson relayed her alarming account to authorities. Meanwhile, Benning’s mother, Bridget, rushed to the hospital and endeavored to understand what happened to her daughter.
Benning had, according to medical professionals, been deprived of oxygen for a significant time, resulting in brain death. Hope for mother and her unborn child was grim.
The responding medical team confirmed traces of cocaine in Benning’s system, a revelation unrecognizable to her family as Benning had eschewed drugs after learning of her pregnancy.
The investigation tasked with assessing Benning’s deteriorating condition involved police speaking with Taylor multiple times. However, no recorded charges implicated him, and no drugs were retrieved from retrieved drinks. Despite Nijaiha’s claims, this unrecorded conversation formed the crux of an ongoing judicial focus.
Following a year-long investigation, police arrested Taylor on March 14, 2024, in Utah, charging him with the murder of Benning and her unborn child. Taylor’s attorneys maintained his innocence, arguing a lack of evidence connecting him to the drugs in question.
During the ensuing trial, prosecutors relied heavily on Jackson’s account and further insights from Taylor’s past, alleging a methodical intent to cause harm without direct links establishing culpability.
The defense countered by questioning witness reliability and the integrity of the scene due to late evidence collection, combined with arguments of alternative, unproven narratives regarding substance exposure.
Despite these defenses, the jury found Taylor guilty of four counts, including second-degree murder of Benning and first-degree murder of the unborn child. He received consecutive life sentences.
Benning’s family find a semblance of justice in the verdict, though their poignant loss remains irreparable. They continue honoring Benning’s legacy, remembering her as a connecting force cherished by her community.
