In Colorado, a federal judge has directed the immediate release of Edgardo Garcia Vargas, who was arrested by immigration officers moments after his release from detention. The judge criticized the government, citing an ‘ongoing due process violation,’ and warned of potential contempt proceedings if further detention occurs without a hearing.
U.S. District Judge S. Kato Crews, a Biden appointee, issued the order stating that Garcia Vargas had been released in line with a previous court directive. However, he was promptly arrested again by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) while still on the detention facility grounds. The judge remarked, ‘Once again, the cruelty appears to be the point.’
This event is part of growing tensions between the Trump administration and federal judges concerning immigration enforcement. Judicial bodies continue to challenge the government’s detention tactics, often accusing immigration authorities of ignoring court orders.
The administration is actively pursuing a broad deportation campaign to amplify arrests and removals. Federal data obtained by the Deportation Data Project via the Freedom of Information Act reveals that immigration arrests in Colorado increased significantly, almost doubling from 259 in March to 499 in July 2026, compared to 549 arrests in July 2025.
Judge Crews dismissed the argument that since Garcia Vargas had technically been released, the court’s habeas relief was fulfilled. He pointed out that the man had effectively remained in custody the entire time. The judge stated that recognizing any other view would negate the meaning of habeas relief and encourage ‘gamesmanship’ by the respondents.
Garcia Vargas claimed his initial arrest was a due process violation as he was not shown a warrant. Judge Crews accepted the due process claim since the government failed to respond to the habeas petition. Thus, the judge ordered Garcia Vargas’ immediate release and instructed the administration to provide a status update within three days to verify his release.
Authorities were prohibited from re-detaining Garcia Vargas without first proving, at a bond hearing, that he poses a flight risk or a community threat. Such proceedings must bear the government’s burden of proof, allowing legal representation for Garcia Vargas.
Judge Crews cautioned that any rearrest without following these due processes could lead to contempt proceedings. He stated, ‘Should Petitioner again be instantly rearrested without receiving the foregoing due process, Respondents shall appear in this Court for consideration of whether contempt proceedings are warranted.’
Individuals named in the court documents include Juan Baltazar, warden of the Aurora Contract Detention Facility, ICE’s acting director David Venturella, and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin.
This ruling emerges amidst another legal confrontation over ICE’s detention activities in Colorado. Previously, a federal judge found the agency repeatedly violated court orders on warrantless arrests. Sanctions were suggested against agents involved in two separate arrests, one of which caused significant injuries to an 18-year-old. The government has appealed the injunction, with arguments scheduled for November 16.
Additionally, ICE is broadening its detention capacity in Colorado. According to Axios Denver, the state’s detention capacity is set to almost double, following increased immigration enforcement efforts by the administration.
For further details on this story, contact Newsweek editors Matthew Cannon and James Debens.
