Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth is under increasing scrutiny. Pressure comes from both political parties, as Republican Representative Thomas Massie moves toward forcing a House impeachment vote and Democrats plan to ramp up oversight come January.
The latest criticism arrived from Republican Representative James Comer. He questioned Hegseth’s leadership and criticized the Trump administration’s approach in Iran. Comer expressed concerns among Republican voters regarding the conflict.
During a conversation with NewsNation, the chairman of the House Oversight Committee was asked about the possibility of Democrats introducing impeachment articles against Hegseth. Comer replied, “That’s a decision President Trump’s going to have to make.” He noted the significant number of questions surrounding Hegseth.
Hegseth faces uncertain prospects after Republican losses in the midterm elections. The Iran conflict has become a major political concern for the administration.
Newsweek reached out to the White House and Department of Defense for comments on the situation.
Why Do They Want to Impeach Pete Hegseth?
Massie, a Republican from Kentucky, plans to present his impeachment resolution when lawmakers reconvene. He announced plans to trigger a vote by early next week.
The resolution includes eight articles of impeachment. Key issues involve Hegseth’s actions in the Iran war, use of military force without congressional approval, and other military operations. Massie accuses Hegseth of violating the War Powers Resolution.
Iran War Concerns
Comer emphasized their uncertainty about the strategy in Iran, stating, “No one’s happy about Iran.” Republican dissatisfaction, Comers added, is particularly strong among Trump supporters.
Vice President JD Vance also linked Republican defeat to the conflict, commenting, “The reason we lost is the war.”
Criticism Over Military Conduct
Massie has criticized Hegseth’s handling of military leadership and sensitive information.
In a post on X, Massie accused Hegseth of incompetence and improper conduct, from dismissing top generals to leaking war plans.
Massie describes his impeachment resolution as more restrained than what Democrats might pursue.
He advises that Trump replace appointees such as Hegseth before Senate confirmation becomes a challenge.
Trump’s Decision on Hegseth
Kathryn Dunn Tenpas of the Brookings Institution suggests Trump may need to remove Hegseth to minimize political damage.
Tenpas indicated that while this might not halt investigations, it could lessen controversy.
Support for Hegseth’s Impeachment
Massie introduced impeachment articles in September, openly declaring he would forgo action should Hegseth resign.
Democrats have expressed support for increased supervision of Hegseth.
Rep. Jason Crow criticized Hegseth’s alleged corruption and impact on national security.
Similarly, Rep. James Walkinshaw endorsed impeachment and noted his intent to vote for it.
Challenges from the Senate
Sen. Thom Tillis called his vote to confirm Hegseth “the biggest regret of my career,” expressing dissatisfaction with Hegseth’s relationship with Congress.
Sen. Ted Cruz anticipated an impeachment effort in the lame-duck session.
For impeachment to occur, the House needs a simple majority, and removal would require a two-thirds Senate majority.
Potential Replacements
If Trump replaces Hegseth, names like Republican Florida Governor Ron DeSantis are under speculation.
CBS News reported DeSantis as one candidate, allowing confirmation before Democrats take Congress.
Hegseth’s public comments and Trump’s defense indicate Hegseth remains in place for now.
Hegseth expressed skepticism regarding replacement rumors for Sen. Marsha Blackburn’s vacated seat.
Whether Trump decides to replace Hegseth hinges on multiple variables: administration strategy, Democratic control, and public opinion.
Opinions on Hegseth’s Potential Departure
Professor Grant Davis Reeher thinks Trump might remove Hegseth after election outcomes.
He noted Hegseth and FBI Director Kash Patel negatively impact approval ratings.
In contrast, Professor Craig Agranoff suggests Trump’s public backing makes an immediate dismissal improbable.
Despite rising pressure, public support implies a potential drawn-out conflict.
Hegseth’s Response and Background
Hegseth dismissed the impeachment as political theater in a video, promising to withstand the pressure.
He accused opposition of destructive political tactics and defended the administration’s Iran policy.
Born in Minneapolis, Hegseth has a distinguished military and media career. Appointed in 2025, his future now rests heavily with Trump’s decision-making.

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller