Menu

Regional Government Success: Portland vs. Twin Cities

5 days ago 0

Regional governments, like the ones established in the 1960s and 1970s in Minneapolis-St. Paul and Portland, aim to tackle urban challenges such as racial inequality and climate change. These governments, the Metropolitan Council in the Twin Cities and the Metro in Portland, were set up to curb urban sprawl, manage traffic congestion, and prevent the social and economic decline of central cities.

Both regions established metro growth boundaries to control development and required communities to provide a fair share of affordable housing. Recent research from the Institute on Metropolitan Opportunity highlights that Portland’s Metro Council effectively reduced racial inequality and decreased household driving. This success contrasts with the Twin Cities, where racial segregation is rising rapidly despite similar policies.

Key demographic similarities include a two-thirds white population and low poverty rates. Both areas have grown steadily. However, from 2000 to 2020, the Twin Cities’ metro boundary grew twice as fast as Portland’s, and the region has struggled to contain urban sprawl effectively. This expansion, coupled with a substantial increase in freeway lane miles, contrasts with Portland’s more restrained development.

Portland enforced its fair share requirements more rigorously. Smaller lot sizes and a higher percentage of rental units (38% versus 26% in the Twin Cities) enabled residents to live closer to good schools. This prevented the social and economic distress seen in Minneapolis and St. Paul, where neighborhoods have become more segregated and impoverished than those in Portland.

Schools in Portland’s neighborhoods attract middle-income families due to mixed-income environments. In contrast, the Twin Cities have a significant number of schools with predominantly nonwhite students, creating education disparities. The Twin Cities also face higher crime rates; Minneapolis experiences a murder rate 83% higher than Portland, with a 43% higher violent crime rate.

Population growth in Portland’s central city outpaces that in Minneapolis and St. Paul due to better schools and lower crime rates. This growth has bolstered Portland’s tax base per capita, allowing for improved public services at lower tax levels compared to the Twin Cities.

If the Met Council enforced laws effectively, the Twin Cities could mirror Portland’s progress in racial justice and climate initiatives. The regional planning framework remains an important achievement, and new leadership in Minnesota should ensure that the Twin Cities benefit from this established structure.

Myron Orfield, Earl R. Larson Professor of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Law at the University of Minnesota, is the director of the Institute on Metropolitan Opportunity.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *