Emmy Hopefuls: Who Critics Are Rooting For This Year

Television critics are closely watching the personalities who bring us our favorite shows during this Emmy season. “The Pitt,” “Hacks,” “Widow’s Bay,” and “Pluribus” are among the top frontrunners for nominations. Here’s a closer look at who critics are hoping to see victorious during the upcoming award ceremony on Monday night.

Outstanding Drama Series: “Pluribus”

In the category for Outstanding Drama Series, HBO Max’s “The Pitt” is seen as a likely winner. However, Apple TV’s “Pluribus” offers a compelling narrative with its revolutionary sci-fi story. A virus originating from messages sent from space unites humanity in a collective hive mind, creating either a utopian society or the world’s largest cult.

Outstanding Lead Actor, Drama: Noah Wyle, “The Pitt”

Noah Wyle’s performance in “The Pitt’s” second season stands out as he brings his character, Dr. “Robby” Rabinovich, to the edge of unlikability. His portrayal of a good guy in deep crisis delves into new depths.

Outstanding Lead Actress, Drama: Rhea Seehorn, “Pluribus”

Much of “Pluribus” focuses on Rhea Seehorn’s character, Carol, navigating the post-apocalyptic world while mourning her spouse. Her captivating performance deserves recognition as she brings depth and emotion to the series.

Outstanding Supporting Actress, Drama: Karolina Wydra, “Pluribus”

Critics hope that Emmy voters recognize Karolina Wydra’s role as Zosia, the global hive mind voice in “Pluribus.” Her performance adds empathy and dimension, complementing Seehorn’s portrayal of Carol.

Outstanding Comedy Series: “Margo’s Got Money Troubles”

Apple TV’s “Margo’s Got Money Troubles” may not look like a typical comedy nominee. The show narrates a young woman’s journey into risky decisions as she builds a life with her baby and eccentric family. It has emerged as an incredibly vibrant and engaging series.

Outstanding Lead Actor, Comedy: Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, “Wonder Man”

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II stands out in “Wonder Man,” despite Marvel canceling the series. His portrayal of a superpowered individual striving to achieve acting success blends humor, emotion, and drama effectively.

Outstanding Lead Actress, Comedy: Lisa Kudrow, “The Comeback”

Despite tough competition, Lisa Kudrow shines as Valerie Cherish in “The Comeback.” She skillfully balances her character’s self-absorption, resilience, and quirkiness, bringing depth and humor to the role.

Outstanding Supporting Actress, Comedy: Kate O’Flynn, “Widow’s Bay”

Kate O’Flynn captivates audiences in “Widow’s Bay,” especially in Episode 4. Her portrayal of Patricia, whose attempts at improving social status fail, is both cringeworthy and mesmerizing.

Outstanding Supporting Actor, Comedy: Nick Offerman, “Margo’s Got Money Troubles”

Nick Offerman reaches new heights in his role as Jinx, a former wrestler and dad facing addiction challenges while supporting his daughter in “Margo’s Got Money Troubles.” His sensitivity and depth shine through.

Outstanding Writing for a Comedy Series: “The Comeback”

“The Comeback” offers perceptive insights into reality TV and streaming dynamics, highlighting AI’s potential pitfalls. This season delivers profound and humorous warnings, making its writing award-worthy.

Outstanding Limited or Anthology Series: “DTF St. Louis”

“DTF St. Louis” emerges as a creative limited series, examining the mysterious death of a man in a love triangle. Jason Bateman and David Harbour lead a poignant, darkly comedic tale of middle-aged despair.

Congratulations are in order for Betty Gilpin, who won the outstanding guest actress in a comedy for “Widow’s Bay,” and to “The Muppet Show” for outstanding writing for a variety special. Although Connor Storrie’s role as an “SNL” guest host didn’t win, the award honoring Rob Reiner for “The Bear” is a fitting tribute.