On Tuesday, Americans will determine which party controls Congress. This will test the accuracy of two indicators often used to predict elections: polls and prediction markets. Both currently suggest a strong Democratic performance.
The RealClearPolling (RCP) average indicates Democrats lead by 8.2 points for the 2026 generic Congressional vote, with 51.4% compared to 43.2% for Republicans. Nate Silver’s average shows a similar trend with Democrats leading by 8.7 points. Prediction markets reinforce this, with Kalshi giving Democrats a 69% chance of Senate control and 92% for a House majority. Polymarket presents similar probabilities.
“The consensus between polls and prediction markets signals potential danger. As political scientists have noted, prediction markets largely interpret poll results. Both have had inconsistencies, and these midterms will test their reliability,” Newsweek states.
Christopher Wlezien from the University of Texas at Austin emphasizes looking for variation in polls, as consistency may indicate issues. Historically, public polls have overstated Democratic support by two to three points, except during midterms like in 2018 and 2022. Columbia University professors note Republican candidates tend to outperform polls, especially with Donald Trump involved.
Alan Abramowitz from Emory University highlights that polling inaccuracies may not be consistent across elections. Last year’s gubernatorial races in New Jersey and Virginia showed errors when Trump wasn’t a candidate. Predictive errors are usually correlated, with nonresponse favoring specific parties across states.
A notable polling mistake involved Wedgewood Polls, which fabricated surveys. This incident impacted reporting, including Newsweek’s coverage. Prediction markets gained attention during the 2024 elections by favoring Trump despite polls suggesting a toss-up.
However, prediction markets face challenges. Kalshi and Polymarket have misjudged several races, such as the Democratic primaries in Florida and Wisconsin, and Brazil’s general elections. Abramowitz doubts prediction markets due to their reliance on polls and commentary. Research supports this viewpoint, suggesting that market prices add errors when departing from polls.
With over $1.4 billion traded on midterm outcomes, federal regulators are addressing insider trading. Kalshi has suspended candidates betting on their own races, and Polymarket has sent cases to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
The upcoming election will test both polls and markets. Polls need the national House vote to align closely with the predicted Democratic lead. Prediction markets should accurately predict outcomes, especially where they backed strong favorites.
“The old advice to bettors is to support the favorites. If the expected Democratic victory happens, both polls and markets were correct. If not, they missed together,” Newsweek concludes.

Mayor Mamdani’s Policing Reform Plans
Gen Z Voter Shifts and Their Impact on the 2026 Midterm Elections
Disappearance of US Senate Candidate Raises Questions
DOJ Rule Change Reduces Appeal Time for Immigrants Facing Deportation
Hakeem Jeffries’ Bid for House Speaker Faces Progressive Hurdles
Ohio Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Rep. Max Miller