A New Hampshire man, Douglas Herlihy, now 40, faces a potential prison sentence of up to 24 years after pleading guilty to the killing of his father over 20 years ago. Herlihy admitted to committing the crime when he was 17, according to the New Hampshire Department of Justice.
Troubled Relationship and Murder Details
The relationship between Douglas Herlihy and his father, Paul Herlihy, was marked by turmoil and previous incidents involving law enforcement. Paul Herlihy, 50, was found deceased on August 27, 2003, during a welfare check initiated by a relative. Authorities discovered his body wrapped in a carpet and tarpaulin in the kitchen of his Milford, New Hampshire home.
Investigators noted signs of struggle. Blood was found on kitchen surfaces, and the autopsy revealed the cause of death to be blunt-force trauma. Injuries included fractures to Paul Herlihy’s skull and damage to his voice box. The evidence suggested multiple blows to the head caused his demise.
In the backyard, police discovered carpet pieces stained with blood that appeared to have been discarded from Douglas Herlihy’s bedroom, which had an open window at the time. DNA analysis indicated the blood might belong to Paul Herlihy.
Years of Evasion and Arrest
Months and years after the death, Douglas Herlihy faced various legal issues, including drug charges and vehicle theft. In 2020, during an arrest, he allegedly boasted about beating past legal challenges, implying past violent deeds. Despite repeated denials to his family, Douglas Herlihy became the focus of renewed investigation by authorities.
In June 2025, based on accumulated evidence, an arrest warrant was issued. Douglas Herlihy was arrested in Saugus, Massachusetts, and extradited to New Hampshire. He faced charges of second-degree murder and falsification of evidence.
Plea Agreement and Commitment to Justice
A plea agreement was reached, resulting in a manslaughter charge with a prison term ranging from 12 to 24 years. An additional sentence for attempting to falsify evidence was suspended for 20 years.
New Hampshire Attorney General John M. Formella praised the investigators for their persistent efforts in solving the cold case, emphasizing the enduring pursuit of justice.
The pursuit of justice does not end with the passage of time.
A sentencing hearing is expected in early 2027. The Herlihy family, seeking privacy, declined media interaction.

Former Hospital Security Guard Convicted for Sexual Conduct with a Dead Body
Northern Illinois University Students Charged After Damaging Mascot Statue
Lindsay Clancy’s Retrial Set for March 29
Former CIA Director’s Son Arrested on Child Pornography Charges
New Charges in White House Correspondents’ Dinner Shooting
New York Fugitive Arrested in Miami Beach for Multiple Assaults