Reviewing theater over the years offers many experiences, but witnessing an actor suffer a heart attack on stage and continue performing was unprecedented. In May 2017, during the opening night of the play Pamplona at the Goodman Theatre, this extraordinary event unfolded. The play, crafted by Jim McGarth, featured a solo performance about Ernest Hemingway. The renowned Stacy Keach starred, who passed away at 85 recently. On that night, Keach was alone on stage, portraying Hemingway in the Spanish town of 1959.
Initially, Keach’s performance seemed typical as his movements slowed, yet nothing seemed amiss. He embodied Hemingway, fully immersing himself in the role. Moments of silence punctuated the performance as if ‘Papa’ Hemingway was seeking his center. The intensity of Keach’s portrayal was palpable, and I noted its brilliance, writing “Incredible” in my notes.
Yet, it soon became evident that something was wrong. Lines were repeated, breaking the performance’s continuity. Director Robert Falls’s hurried departure from the theater added to my growing concern. Despite these signs, Keach soldiered on.
“I felt,” Keach recounted, “like this great fog had come over me. It was the most bizarre moment of my entire career.”
This ‘fog’ seemed eerily reminiscent of Hemingway’s words in The Sun Also Rises: “A fog had come over the mountains from the sea…” Keach’s experience on stage could be likened to an actor’s nightmare—forgetting lines, missing cues, or not knowing the play being performed.
Keach confessed to feeling lost, as Hemingway’s struggle with writer’s block mirrored his own battle to remember his lines. “I was aware that I was in a state of repetition,” he admitted. Ultimately, the stage manager’s announcement, over what theater people call the “Voice of God,” saved the situation: “Mr. Keach, please leave the stage.” Keach obliged, soon finding himself in an ambulance headed to the hospital.
Reflecting later, I questioned whether Keach would have continued indefinitely without the intervention. His eventual response was a resolute “No;” he would have persisted. The commitment to the theater mantra, “the show must go on,” was evident in his resolve.
A year later, Keach returned to the Goodman Theatre, reprising the same role. On asking about his decision, he confidently stated, “I’m going to get back on the horse.” This time, he flawlessly transformed into Hemingway, the “Voice of God” remaining silent as he delivered a powerful performance. This episode demonstrated not only Keach’s resilience but also a deep reverence for his craft, offering a memorable experience to all who witnessed it.
Chris Jones, a Tribune critic, [email protected]

Jennifer Lopez Discusses Marriage and Humor During 92NY Event
Teri Hatcher’s Makeup Transformation into Miranda Priestly
AEW’s Blood and Guts: A Glimpse into the Brutal Spectacle
Author Discusses Challenges with ‘Children of Blood and Bone’ Film Adaptation
Valerie Bertinelli Reminisces About ‘Hot in Cleveland’
Judi Dench’s Beauty Secrets and Her Journey with Aging