Aaron Rodgers’ Return to Steelers Supported by Joe Theismann

The Pittsburgh Steelers have brought Aaron Rodgers back for another season. Super Bowl champion Joe Theismann credits Mike McCarthy as a key factor in Rodgers’ decision to return.

Theismann, 76, expressed that Rodgers’ return seemed obvious to him because of McCarthy’s presence. Theismann stated, “I think Aaron coming back was a no-brainer for me because Mike McCarthy’s there.” He emphasized that if Rodgers faced learning a completely new system and playbook, the decision might have been different.

Aaron Rodgers of the Pittsburgh Steelers stands during the national anthem before an NFL game against the Baltimore Ravens at Acrisure Stadium in Pittsburgh, Pa., on Jan. 4, 2026. (Michael Owens/Getty Images)

McCarthy and Rodgers had previously spent 13 years with the Green Bay Packers. Their past experience together ensures a seamless transition. As Theismann highlighted, since there is familiarity with the system, Rodgers does not need extensive time in OTAs to grasp terminology or master play reads. Comfort with the current system is an advantage for Rodgers.

Last season, the four-time NFL MVP proved his continued effectiveness by completing 65.7% of his passes for 3,322 yards, with 24 touchdowns and seven interceptions across 16 games. Despite his talent, Rodgers, now 42, has reduced mobility compared to his prime years.

Rodgers can certainly still throw the ball well, but at 42 years old his mobility isn’t what it once was. Theismann discussed the importance of the offensive line’s performance, acknowledging, “He’s going to get the ball out of his hands quickly. But they’re going to have to shore up the offensive line and protect him.” Successful protection can allow Rodgers to hold the ball and make impactful downfield passes.

The Steelers will have their first new head coach in almost two decades. However, Theismann predicts that the team’s identity will remain intact. “Pittsburgh is still going to be Pittsburgh,” he said. “They play in a tough division and it’s all about toughness. Aaron has shown how tough he can be.”

Former NFL player Joe Theismann talks with sportscaster Chris Collinsworth before the game between the Seattle Seahawks and Washington Commanders at Northwest Stadium in Landover, Md., on Nov. 2, 2025. (Greg Fiume/Getty Images)

Theismann’s NFL career spanned 12 seasons, all with the Washington Redskins. He was the 1983 league MVP and appeared in two Pro Bowls. He led the Redskins to victory in Super Bowl XVII with a score of 27-17 against the Miami Dolphins.

Theismann will participate in the American Century Championship at Edgewood Golf Course in Lake Tahoe from July 10-12. The competition will be broadcast on NBC and Peacock.